Archive for November, 2010

WaTunes: Web 2.0 Summit 2010: A Conversation with Mark Zuckerberg of Facebook!

November 30, 2010 at 12:06 am Leave a comment

WaTunes: TuneCore’s CEO Jeff Price On Going Direct to iTunes

Source: Hypebot

Jeff Price, CEO of TuneCore, responds to a recent post on Digital Music News.

image from This posting is not about me trying to drum up business for TuneCore. Rather, a recent music blog ran a factually incorrect and incomplete story about how artists can “go direct” with digital stores like iTunes. It’s frustrating to see wrong information being stated as fact as misinformation can hurt artists. I thought it important to provide a more complete story.

To begin, the article implies that a "submit an application for iTunes” link recently became available.  This is not the case. This link has been live and available since the day iTunes launched.  One of the reasons I started TuneCore is that many digital stores will not do deals directly with most artists, requiring them to go through a middleman. This is not because the digital stores do not like or value artists, it is because of the support, logistics and liability issues that exist around being a digital store. 

For example, many of these contracts run over twenty pages and require a physical copy to be signed and mailed back. In the event the digital stores allowed all artists to sign up directly, they would need to physically snail mail out millions of paper contracts and wait for an original signed copy back (a scanned PDF emailed does not suffice). In addition, the signer of the agreement must be over 18 years and have an attorney on their end read it over to avoid any possible legal issues. As many of the companies that run digital stores are publicly traded, they would very much need this procedure followed.

Term Issues

In addition to then having to file millions of contracts, each one would have a different expiration date around the Term – this means that there must be a schedule kept as to when each of these contracts expires. Prior to expiration, they would need to "renew,” and while there could be an auto-renew trigger in the agreements that may address this, the Term still needs to be kept track of in the event the digital store would like to discontinue the relationship.

On top of the Term issue, there is also the amendment issue: for example, since launching, the digital stores have added new provisions, territories and options to each agreement. For each new amendment (i.e. complete my album, DRM free, expansion into another territory, longer preview clip streams, and so on) additional paperwork must be sent out. This paperwork would then need to be physically signed and snail mailed back and attached to the appropriate agreement it is associated with.

Each contract also has a confidentiality clause: in the event any of the contract holders posted any information from the agreements, the digital store would contact the contract holder about a potential material breach of contract (not to mention they now need to police this as well).

Add to this that each time a digital store would like to do a promotion around a free giveaway, a feature, etc., they will also need to reach out to each entity separately and get even more paperwork signed off on and sent back.

Music Issues

On top of the legal issues, with each agreement would also come the additional artist support and issues about how to get music, metadata and art to the digital store.  For example, what is AAC, what is an MP3, how do I get my file to be 44.1 khz, I only have my music as an MP3 how do I make it a lossless AAC, WMA, WAV etc file?  I don’t have a fast net connection and cannot upload.  My net cut out during upload. What is a UPC, what is a song identifier, do I need an ISRC, how do I get them?  How do I make a 600 x 600 300 dpi image? In some cases the digital stores switch formats and have asked for the music to be resent to them in a new codec (for example, please re-deliver your songs to us as 256kb, 44.1 khz, MP3s as opposed to a .Wav)

Then move onto other issues – I uploaded the wrong track, I need to take the release down, I need to change the name of the song, I misspelled the title, I need to add Japan but remove the UK.  I fired my manager but he has the account details and access, please change it to me and so on.

Legal Issues

Then there are the legal issues – many artists do not know the intimacies of copyright law – some infringe on copyright without knowing they are, others infringe well aware they are breaking the law, still others have fraud schemes.  If these artist are going direct, the digital store becomes more directly legally liable to be sued, whereas if the digital store gets the music via a larger "middleman", that middleman has to warrant and represent the music is free and clear of claims.  In the event the music is infringing on copyright, the middleman takes the liability hit and legal challenge. The middleman also typically has “deeper pockets” and is able to settle the claim.

Now add on top of this the millions of emails and phone calls from each contract holder trying to get feature placement. As a reference point, imagine millions of artists calling Rolling Stone magazine directly to get an album review as opposed to a smaller group of publicists.

And that's just to get the music in.

Now there are the issues around getting the money out – you need a bank account that can take direct deposit (not that big of a deal for many of us, but there are some that do not have this).  Most of the digital stores do not mail out checks, they do electronic direct deposit as they do not have the infrastructure to physically mail out checks and paperwork to the existing entities they work with. Then there are the challenges of wrong bank account info and bounced EFTs.  How does this money make it out?  The stores need to reach the customer and cannot due to a fictitious email, wrong phone number, transfer of rights and death of the copyright holder or address unknown. 

Incomplete Story

Holding onto the money from the sale of the music creates financial and legal liability.  If it remains uncollected, after a period of time, income tax most likely will have to be paid on it by the digital store.

Then there is the customer support around the monthly statements – i.e. “I know I sold a song in January, but it's not showing it, why?”   Because January sales are reported in March.  “Why did I make less/more than what I expected?” Due to the music selling in Japan at a different rate, being sent to your U.S. bank account and your bank doing a Yen to Dollar conversion.  “How come a % of my money is not being paid to me from Australian sales?” Because there is a tariff imposed by the Australian government due to international trade treaties.  “Why am I losing 25% of my sales income from songs sold in Japan?” Because you have not filed a form required by the Japanese government to eliminate this fee. And this list too goes on and on.

As to why someone would choose to run an incomplete story as fact I can only speculate – either they really did not know (in which case they really did not do any investigation and should run the article with a disclaimer) or they may be trying to run sensational news stories in an attempt to drive chatter, eyeballs and ultimately ad dollars into their pockets.  There is nothing wrong with this, provided the blog states it is an opinion piece. The challenge is when someone creates an "official" sounding name and states something as fact knowing it's not to make money via web traffic and get the sort of financial exit TechCrunch did.

But more importantly, artists should be provided with as much clear and accurate information as possible to allow them to pursue their goals.  This misinformation only hurts.

November 24, 2010 at 5:20 pm Leave a comment

WaTunes: eMusic Reboots With UMG Catalog, Sony & WMG New Releases plus A Reply To Exiting Indies

Source: Hypebot

image from Many of the promised changes at eMusic are launching today. "We are adding to our U.S. catalogue over 250,000 titles from Universal Music Group, as well as new releases from Sony and Warner Music," wrote eMusic CEO Adam Klein. New music from major labels is something new for the subscription service and much of it goes live today (11/18)  in the U.S. But the expansion has not come without controversy.

Just  yesterday, eMusic announced the loss of threse respected independent labels: Domino, Merge and the Beggars Group of labels which includes 4AD and Matador.  Responding to the departures Klien says: "In the process of expanding our catalog and making the changes necessary to serve our members and ensure the long-term sustainability of our business, a few labels have chosen to exclude themselves from the new comprehensive eMusic offering.  We are treating all labels equally and therefore we believe fairly.  We will greatly miss their artists and their music and trust that they will find their way back to our members soon."

Many eMusic subscribers appear to miss these artists as well, judging from the comments in the site's forum. "The labels who made emusic's footprint as large as it is are getting hosed and they know it," wrote one.

And at least one of the departing labels, Beggars, seems in no hurry to return. "We wish this hadn’t happened, but as eMusic has brought major labels on board, they have changed the terms on which they deal with labels in certain ways, some of which we have found impossible to accept, in our own interests, those of our artists, and ultimately those of their fans," said the UK indie label group in a statement.

November 18, 2010 at 10:34 pm Leave a comment

WaTunes: On Eve Of Relaunch, eMusic Loses 3 Key Indie Labels. Subscribers Not Happy.

Source: Hypebot

<img class="asset asset-image at-xid-6a00d83451b36c69e20133f5f6183d970b" title="image from” src=”; alt=”image from” style=”margin: 0px 5px 5px 0px;” /> Just days before a major relaunch, eMusic has lost three respected independent label groups. Music from Domino, Merge and the Beggars Group of labels which includes 4AD and Matador and artists like  Arcade Fire, Spoon, Belle & Sebastian, Cat Power, and Yo La Tengo will no longer be available as of November 18th. eMusic is scheduled to change subscription pricing later this month as it adds 250,000 tracks from UMG, the last major label to come aboard.

eMusic notified subscribers in an email Tuesday, but offered no reason for the change. On the eMusic forum, the reaction was negative with more than one subscriber predicting eMusic's decline and offering their own explanation of why indie labels are leaving the service:

"its inevitable. the math is straight-forward and its not good for the smaller labels when they have to compete against big back catalogs from the majors. add to it they were the ones who took all the risk in going digital many years before the bigs. this is their way of saying 'thx for screwing us over.'

"let me be perfectly clear: at the pricing you're moving to, emusic will primarily be a distributor for the big labels – hell, make it exclusively. the labels who made emusic's footprint as large as it is are getting hosed and they know it."

"i can't see how you can turn back, but really – at this point we're all looking at this as "you made your bed…"


November 17, 2010 at 6:08 pm Leave a comment

WaTunes: From WMG Earnings Call: EMI, Spotify & The Cloud

Source: Hypebot

<img class="asset asset-image at-xid-6a00d83451b36c69e2013489162317970c" title="image from” src=”; alt=”image from” style=”margin: 0px 5px 5px 0px;” /> On this mornings earnings call, Warner Music Group CEO Edgar Bronfman Jr and his team did their best to explain financials that showed declining revenue, slow digital growth and a business plan centered on extracting more rights and revenue from artists, as well as, continued cost cutting. (More on the financial statement here.) But Bronfman also shared some carefully worded insights into the broader music industry:

  • Bromfman touted a new "difficult to reach" agreement with Spotify in the EU, but hinted that any U.S. launch was up to other labels. That's a softening of his previous position which was far more anti music streaming.
  • He refused to speculate about what might happened next at EMI and if WMG would make a bid.
  • While not offering specifics on Google or any other service, Bronfman stated that music in the cloud offered a "significant opportunity" to turn the business around and suggested major action in the space should happen early next year.
  • Declining ringtone sales continued to be the music group's justification for slow overall digital revenue growth.

November 17, 2010 at 6:03 pm Leave a comment

WaTunes: THIS WEEK – Rihanna, Nelly, The Beatles, Rascal Flatts, Keith Urban + Lil Wayne SPECIAL

This week's latest releases comes to no surprise. From Rihanna's Loud to Nelly's 5.0. We got all the music you want, right now! We also would like to give a out a huge spotlight to Lil Wayne. Be sure to download all of his greatest albums only on WaTunes!

1: Rihanna – Loud
2: Keith Urban – Get Closer
3: Rascal Flatts – Nothing Like This
4: Nelly – 5.0 (Deluxe)

November 17, 2010 at 12:07 am Leave a comment

WaTunes: Warner Music Group Plannning $750M EMI Bid

Source: Hypebot

image from Terra Firma's Guy Hands and EMI CEO Roger Faxon claim they have no intention of selling EMI.  But its doubtful that their largest lender Citigroup agrees, and since loosing his lawsuit woth the bank, Hands may have no choice. Eager, as he has in the past to take advantage of EMI's struggles is Edgar Bronfman Jr's Warner Music Group, who The Guardian reports is once again readying a $750 million fire sale price bid for EMI's recorded music division that should be delivered to Terra Firma within weeks.

Citigroup reportedly supports selling EMI's recorded music as part of a debt reduction plan.  Another possible scenario could see Citigroup offering to cancel debt in return for taking control of EMI's profitable music publishing division. That would also clear the way for a merger of EMI and WMG.

EMI appears likely to become in breach of its loan covenants when the next review happens in March.  If that is true, the only way that Hands can avoid Citi forcing a sale or takeover appears to be if already beleaguered Terra Firma investors agree to pump still more cash into EMI.

November 16, 2010 at 12:01 am Leave a comment

WaTunes: Connect Your Artist Ping Profile with Twitter for Music Discovery

November 12, 2010 at 5:19 pm Leave a comment


November 2010

Posts by Month

Posts by Category